Humility is a word that has
been thrown around a lot during our time together. What does it mean to you in
the context of educational research and, more specifically how might it relate
to your field of study/discipline.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
May 24…On the Nature of a Discipline or Field of Study…Steward of What?
Have you ever thought about the potential for unintended consequences in acquiring disciplinary expertise? While one m...
-
Ask a question about Dewey/pragmatism. Ask another question that the chapter provoked related educational research. Comme...
-
Please share any questions raised by this book and any other thoughts you have. While I hope you learned a lot about prag...
-
At some point this semester, please post a link to an article, video, website, etc. that made you think about something ...
Humility is a word frequently used as a positive trait referring to the practice of humbleness. It carries the same meaning in the context of educational research. I recall our early discussion in the course about the relationship and role of the educational researcher and practitioner. The researcher identifies problems, conducts research, and presents findings based on the results. The practitioner also identifies concerns but performs a more informal analysis to address the situation. There is value in the approach of the researcher and the practitioner. However, these two roles are not interconnected enough. It is unfortunate that members of society view the researcher's contribution as more valuable than the practitioner in the field. The practice of humility by all participants in educational research helps minimize the concern that emerges from placing a higher value on the researcher.
ReplyDeleteAcademic researchers should understand that their contribution is as significant as the practitioner's contribution. Humility should be practiced at all times and the researcher should be open to ideas, experiences, and suggestions from the practitioner. Persons performing direct service should display the same reciprocal actions and interact confidently with researchers as their voices matter as well. After all, humility is a valuable character trait for an individual to practice so that they will always be in a position where they can learn new things and be able to identify gaps and opportunities for growth. I think about the critical theory perspective as it relates to the concept of humility. The critical perspective lens recognizes the importance of the researcher bringing power relationships to the forefront and critiquing them. However, the paradigm emphasizes the necessity of the researcher considering how their participation in the research could be representative of a power relationship. This thought process requires humility on the researchers part as a thorough self-examination. Again, humility is a valuable trait to embody and practice.
Humility urges two primary responsibilities in maintaining its presence as a key role in the context of educational research: first to oneself as an perpetual practitioner and ever-growing professional and one to the teaching and learning of all individuals who make up each component within learning community.
ReplyDeleteIn my specific field of study and discipline, humility holds a seat in that in learning differences historically divides between the needs and the need nots of teaching and learning accommodations. Humility requires that one level the playing field in a way opposite than is colloquially and frequently discussed - to level the field in this context emphasizes the pupil be regarded with equal importance to the educator and “experts” in order for all members of the school culture to expand our knowledge, exploration, and understanding of what constitutes learning differences and how these may prove relevant to benefit and grow our knowledge as practitioners and learners to the broader contexts of knowledge acquisition and application.
I am applauding your answer! As a teacher in the field of exceptional education I feel that everyone speaks to diversity but do not include students with exceptional needs in that conversation. My students have been left out of too many events and conversations. My role as an educator has been to make sure they have equal participation along their general ed peers. A dose of humility in this respect would be a breath of fresh air.
DeleteBeing in a position where, as researchers, we have access to current literature, resources, and communities of practice and discourse, it is important to remember the goal- the enhancement and upliftment of our social world. Often, having access to a plethora of resources prevents us from feeling humble- making us feel, as a community of researchers, exclusive and elite. It is essential to bear in mind that often the effectiveness of our research outcomes are put into practice by teachers and other practitioners, and it is based on those trials that further changes or new practices are designed and developed for implementation. Additionally, in order to get scholarly work and research out to the different communities, researchers must make their work accessible and understandable to lay people (teachers, parent, practitioners, administrators, etc). Being public intellectuals is a major part of the job description that is often left out and is not apparent in the way that it ought to be- to help break down the barriers of elitism, of 'us versus them'.
ReplyDeleteWith respect to my research interest, I align with critical theory and how it relates to the concept of humility. The practice of restraining and/or secluding children in schools can be understood in framework of power imbalances and oppression of the "weaker" communities (in this case, students with disabilities, students of color, minorities, etc.). These power imbalances and acts of oppression suggest a lack of humility on the part of those using punitive, discriminatory, and persecutory practices. Viewing and treating all individuals as equals, regardless of their age, sex, disability, race, etc., and possessing the continuous desire to learn and adapt to differences all point towards traits of humility.
Toshna Pandey
7-3-18
ReplyDeleteOn humility… In class, I often hear fellow PhD students mention how “troubled” or “troubling” they find certain educational practices or theories to be. They almost always seem to append “I’m doing it for the students/kids” or “I’m doing it for the teachers/schools/education” as carefully considered (contrived?) position statements. These statements often ring quite hollow, especially considering some of the very trendy dissertation areas (with titles that almost always have “intersectionality” embedded in them somewhere) that they have batted around discussion groups. As an English teacher, I know that my goal is to help my students achieve the most they can in my classroom. I act upon my goal every day and teaching really has come to define me as a person. The act of teaching incorporates the idea of humility, especially when we, as teachers, recognize that we serve our students’ educational needs. But what happens at the PhD level? Do teachers who are studying to become educational researchers retain their humility and come to understand that their new purpose is to better the field, and, thus, improve the opportunities and lives of teachers and students? I don’t know. I know fellow PhD students who truly embrace their humility and want to ensure that the work they do empowers teachers and students. But I also know fellow students who see the PhD as nothing more than a ticket to a place far away from the students and colleagues they knew when they were teachers themselves. I’d like to think that I fall into the first category, and most days, I’m pretty sure that I do. At this point in my research journey, I feel very strongly about a quantitative approach to self-regulated strategy development in writing instruction, because I want to give my colleagues the tools they need to help their students improve in written composition and rhetoric. I want to continue to serve students by serving their teachers, because that’s what a PhD will help me achieve. It’s a “force multiplier” and will extend my reach to far more students than I can reach as a classroom teacher. So instead of pursuing dissertations and research tracks that might dovetail nicely with trendy zeitgeists in education, perhaps we should remember that we have an obligation and a duty to the teachers and students who should be the ultimate beneficiaries of our work.
Pete Willis
Marshall:
ReplyDeleteFor a group of people who have chosen a field of study with “leadership” in the title, humility is very important and historically, often in short supply. The history of educational leadership did not address humility as much as is necessary, with the field finding its roots in educational management and educational administration disciplines. The research and practice of the early years in the discipline surrounded systems management and organizational theory, and that called for strong and efficient decision-makers, not humility. The push towards a business-style leadership of the 1990’s similarly skipped this key characteristic. It is only in the last twenty years, with emerging research into the benefits of distributed leadership and into leaders for educational practicing servant leadership, that humility has emerged as a necessity. In practice, I cannot think of a more important trait, as the 100 teachers, 1700 students and thousands of parents I serve are tough critics and can spot arrogance and false bravado quickly.
Another side of educational leadership research involves analyzing and evaluating effective programs and processes for positive educational gains. Humility has a significant role in finding what works. Whether in producing or consuming research, a school leader or educational researcher who believed that he or she has the (capital-R) Right answer for anything in education is likely doing students a disservice. The best researchers and educational leaders are humble enough to know that everything in educational research involves context and nuance and any claim that something “works” must be made with a significant amount of humility.
As I just finished watching something about "gene editing", I am thinking about humility in research, and how a little humility can help guide us. The segment I watched discussed how this scientific breakthrough can possibly help eradicate hereditary diseases in the future, and how great would that be. On the other hand, it brings up all kinds ethical issues. In other words, just because we can does it mean that we should? I think this is where having humility is needed.
ReplyDeleteThis made me think about educational research and unintended consequences. In most cases our research is not as dire as gene editing. However, I do think about all of the things we do in education that have unintended consequences that usually adversely affect our most vulnerable populations. I think about charter schools, Race to the Top, Common Core, SOL, and all of the other things that some great intellectuals just knew would solve the problems of education. Maybe, just maybe, a little bit of humility would have given us pause.
My hope is that I will not get carried away with the excitement of my research and forget to operate with caution, and yes, humility. Whether it is in scientific research, psychological research, or educational research humility is needed to keep intellectuals from feeling like we have all the answers, or the best new thing. Humility and educational research.... just because we can, does that mean we should?
Earlier in our class we talked about humility as “the limits of disciplinarity theory/research that comes with being social beings.” These limits should set the parameters for researchers to share information in a way that honors the participants. In educational research, this means the students or teachers that participate. All researchers, scholar and public intellectual, should maintain awareness of a participants’ values, beliefs, and needs throughout all stages of the research process. This humility by an educational researcher reflects the genuine empathy shared with the participants, and hopefully those reading the results.
ReplyDeleteMy discipline is literacy. I’ve spent much of my time in public schools helping elementary and middle school students who struggle with reading and writing skills. I am humbled every day when I sit down with a small group or one-on-one with students and their determination to learn to be a better reader or writer. I am also humbled by their teachers, who work with 20+ students in a classroom at a time, and are always looking for the “best fit instruction” for their students. Humility is a necessary trait for educational researchers of literacy, because the participants are working to their best ability and in most cases, giving it all they have. As I move forward with literacy as my focus, I will work to instill this level of humility in the pre-service teachers I work with, so that when they lead their own classroom, they will remember the “struggle is real” and that students (and colleagues) need to feel valued.
For me, humility is acknowledging that as an educational researcher there is much to know and I cannot know it all. It means understanding that there are different paradigms or perspectives that shape our knowledge of truth and that there are many truths. It is important that this understanding of humility is imbedded in all I do as this is the only way that I can truly learn, not just from my professors and colleagues, but from those who are not in academia who also experience their own reality. Sometimes this may involve the risk of admitting that one does not know what one is expected to know and opening oneself to scrutiny (not only with regards to writing) (reference to what Pamela Richards says in Becker 2007).
ReplyDeleteIn my discipline of educational leadership, I see humility holding the key to progress. From the perspective of a pragmatist who agrees with Dewey’s action-theoretical framework - that theory and practice are cyclical, feeding into each other; humility is needed to accept that there is no real difference between science and common sense, and educational research and practice; both are nothing without the other. Humility is what allows the producers of knowledge in the discipline to ask how useful is the knowledge produced and what difference it makes to society. Humility also aks that producers and users of knowledge look for ways to ensure that the use of knowledge informs the production of new knowledge.
As I explore my interest on the issue of ‘belonging’ and educational outcomes, I see humility helping me set aside any preconceived notions I have about minorities and disadvantaged communities in the United States. It is a must if I am going to be able to listen and learn from these communities. Even though my aim is to help them improve their learning outcomes, and I will be armed with evidence from previous research, humility means that I cannot ram this knowledge down their throats. Humility asks that I hear what they say and be willing to accept that previous knowledge may be incorrect.
Humility as a scholar means finding a balance between being an "expert" in your discipline, but also knowing that there is a lot that you don't know and someone else might know better than you. I think humility is imperative if any real change can happen in education. If we are not willing to listen to each other rather than just telling others "the way it is" or "the best way" then nothing will change. Of course it is important to know as much as possible in your field, but in order to do so, we have to rely on others to know as much as they can in their own fields. We cannot expect that any of us has the capacity to know everything about all fields!
ReplyDeleteOne place I hope to see more humility than I do currently is between academics and school practitioners. I feel that a lot of important work doesn't get done because both sides think they know best. Scholars think they can help with some of the struggles in schools, but practitioners often don't think that research takes into account many of the factors they face each day. Unfortunately, there is a reluctance to listen to each other or work together on projects. I think that if there was more humility on both sides much of the judgment and resistance could be resolved. Instead of insisting that either one knows better, I hope that we can acknowledge that both professionals have knowledge that can help the other. It would also save time if practitioners and academics would work together to design research projects. If we can all be a little more humble we may actually get stuff done!
Humility is very important to me as a researcher in research and evaluation. I think it helps me to be thorough and studious in my research. I want to make sure that my report or my findings did not misinterpret anything or omit some very important elements (political, social, economic, cultural, and theoretical) in my findings and recommendations. Because those would have some serious impact on how my stakeholders would proceed or modify their programs or projects.
ReplyDeleteSecondly, being humble is very important for me as a researcher/person. I think it is a brave thing for people to willingly accept the criticism (challenge) and willingly to admit the mistake and take the responsibility. I think this would make research much more meaningful, especially for quantitative research.
Finally, being humble also allows me to stop caring so much about perfection, because there is not research or program is perfect. There will always be room for progress and improvement. Therefore, it would help me to get things done and feel good about it.
Humility is a life long lesson, it is something that we as humans are taught from childhood through adulthood. It is a lesson that we continuous learn. Humility is a quality or characteristic which is of utmost importance to me as I believe carrying humility with you makes you a more loving, supportive and compassionate person. Now some my ask why does it matter if you are those qualities listed above if you are a researcher?
ReplyDeleteHumility in research is a quality that makes research exceptional and also helps close the research to practice gap. When a research practice and embraces humility they are willing to acknowledge that they are not perfect, that they make mistakes, and most importantly that they are not better than anyone. We are all here together.
In regard to the researcher, practitioner discussion humility brings in a sense that not one of those areas is better than the other. Therefore, if we practice humility we can work together, not create a hierarchical amongst ourselves, and better serve our community and students.
Humility makes research more approachable.
I look forward to our last class tonight!
Kindly,
Erin Stehle
Humility is not only a beneficial practice when thinking about research, but in life as well. Even though we are attempting to develop expertise in a focused area of research there will always be points of view that could differ, but still be beneficial. I see research, and life, as a process, or journey. We will never reach perfection, but we will learn along the way. It is our duty as researchers to share this knowledge as we go, but we will never know everything.
ReplyDeleteWhen thinking of humility in educational research, I consider my relationship with the term “expert.” No matter the number of years I will conduct research in areas related to my discipline, I do not believe I would ever consider myself a true expert because I will never know everything there is to know about phenomenon like self-determination, culturally-responsive teaching, or post-secondary transition. New knowledge will replace the old, and what is current today, might be history tomorrow. Furthermore, what works in some situations will be disastrous in others. This means I will never stop learning, from my research and from others. Similar to my experiences in K-12 classroom settings, where I continuously learned alongside my students, I will continue to do so as a researcher, regardless of title or position.
ReplyDeleteKatie
When it comes to education and learning new methods and techniques to meet the needs of the populations we intend to serve comes with great humility. As practitioners, we do not have access to all of the answers much of the what we accept as knowledge is partial and incomplete. Therefore, unless we can humble ourselves, we may find ourselves justifying blindspots when it comes to practices. In my experience, I have discovered that people often reject what they do not understand and it requires one to accept failing to recognize and embracing humility is one of the first steps in the process. For example, my entire life I have been told by educators that I am an excellent writer and have a captivating way of articulating my ideas. However, since becoming a graduate student, I have learned that I am a novice when it comes to technical writing. My experience this first year has humbled me to gain a better understanding of my areas of need.
ReplyDeleteI think humility is especially needed within the field of social justice. When you consider critical theory and/or Foucault, many times researchers are participating within the very structures they are seeking to change. Therefore, humility is necessary, because you must be able to reconsider your research, and hold it up to scrutiny. Therefore, willingness to change and scrutiny are aspects of humility.
ReplyDeleteIn addition, researchers must consider that they rarely hold onto all of the knowledge. The fact that educational leaders are often in the center of the system means that we do not have a fully objective vantage point. We must have enough humility to incorporate other views and perspectives.
Personally, humility leads me to honoring differences, seeking to incorporate other voices, and understanding that I much to learn. "Expert" is an elusive term, and rightfully so. I prefer to consider that all of us are learning, and that we can only offer our best opinions in the moment. Finally, humility reminds me to become a public intellectual, ensuring that I learn is shared with my community, and those who could most benefit.
Educational research should be done by those who are humble and without an agenda. The goal of inquiry should be to first identify the problem find possible solutions. Research should be done with equity and ethics on board. An important part of inquiry is to have an open mind and to listen to all points of view. Everyone has their story, and their story is important.
ReplyDeleteIn my field of study there is so much that is not working. We need all stakeholders to contribute and share responsibility for outcomes and fully contribute to identifying what the issues are and how we can provide possible solutions. There is a lot of discussion about what the problems are. What we need are different strategies-many even radical strategies. While we consider all of this our students are paying the price. Perhaps if we were all more humble we could cause less harm to them. Shouldn’t they (the students) really be the bottom line?
Fa Zhang
ReplyDeleteHumility is the quality of being humble. Dictionary definitions accentuate humility as a low self-regard and sense of unworthiness. In educational research, it is very essential to be cautious and humble in conclusion and causality because education is in the domain of research in human beings and social science. In psychology, humility is regarded as a positive virtue. I know researchers in their professional fields are experts, but learning to be humble is a lesson for every one. The methodology and technique change, and situation may differ, so do the different cultural and social backgrounds of students and teachers. We may be not familiar with what they experienced resulting in various cognitive and affective factors. As in Educational Psychology, we are researching on the people's brains--what are students' and teachers' minds working on, and what are their brains thinking of. There's many to explore as it's complex and generalized by multiple elements. Always keep in mind, being humble.